Skip to Main Content

Risk Management & Ministry Protection

Posted: July 1 2025 at 11:54 AM
Author: Elizabeth Stahl, NIC Risk Manager


Risk Image Cmyk

I am excited to start my new challenge as your risk manager. My name is Elizabeth Stahl; I go by Beth. I have worked at Allstate for the last 20 years, have a financial and insurance background, have worked on property management, and I am a lifelong United Methodist. My mom, Martha Schmidt, is a retired Methodist pastor from this conference. I am an active member at the United Methodist Church of Antioch. I welcome the opportunity to bring my skills and dedication to this role to support your church and am committed to ensuring that congregations work on their missions and know that they have a robust risk conscious infrastructure backing them.

I am grateful for the gracious welcome from Elaine Moy, NIC’s treasurer and director of administrative services, who noted that I have “the knowledge and skills of insurance, and the heart for this ministry.”  

While at Allstate/HJS Financial Consulting Group, I worked as a personal financial representative. This sharpened my skills in financial analysis, sales and customer service communication and presentation, problem-solving and decision-making, and budgeting and project planning.

I started on June 2, a week before Annual Conference. Before that I was like most parishioners: very active in my local church and but knowing very little about the conference. I have learned that there is an extraordinarily strong resolute team working for your church, dedicated to doing what is best in its entirety for the conference. Also, they are all helpful, initiative-taking, and genuinely nice people and so have made the start of a new position a positive experience. Thank you!

I met many people at Annual Conference and look forward to meeting many more. I want to work with each church to facilitate managing the risk at your church the most effective way we can. Effective risk management is a collaborative effort. I welcome dialogue on the challenges that your church is facing so we can meet those needs.  

While we know there is some loss that is out of our control, we know how we can mitigate risk, and I am ready to work on implementing strategies with you. As stated in Proverbs 14:15, “the simple believe everything but the prudent gives thought to his steps.” By looking at our risk, we can make more informed decisions and take initiative-taking measures to avoid needless exposure.

The following are my priority areas of focus: 

  • Safety on our properties and off (transportation)  
  • Maintenance of properties; maintenance plans with local church board of trustees 
  • Safe Sanctuaries training and documentation of completion 
  • Education: Webinars, newsletter articles, resources on the website, and collaboration with your board of  trustees on seasonal items. 

Please review the Risk Management web page for resources. There is a lot of information there now and I will continue to add to it.  

I look forward to mitigating risk as much as possible to protect our ministries. Please email me if you have any questions or concerns.

News & Announcements

Thank You

Showing Appreciation for Pastors Throughout October

October is Pastor Appreciation Month, an opportunity to recognize the pastors and clergy who serve congregations and communities throughout the year. From writing a personal…

Nic Collections End July 2024 Cmyk

Have you made your contribution?

In an effort to be more transparent, the Finance and Administration office is going to be consistently sharing where we are as a conference are in regards to the giving versus what is needed fo…

Schoolforleadship

School of Leadership Focuses on Innovation and Connection

More than 250 clergy from Wisconsin and Northern Illinois gathered at Green Lake for three days of leadership development, connection and innovation, exploring new ways…

20260930 Megan Tobola1

Churches Call For Peace in a Divided World

Christians from diverse traditions gathered Sept. 30 at Fourth Presbyterian Church in Chicago for an ecumenical service calling for peace amid division, violence and political mistru…

Print