Skip to Main Content

Bishops challenge constitutionality of disaffiliation petition

Posted: March 6 2019 at 07:04 PM

The Council of Bishops of The United Methodist Church (COB) has asked the Judicial Council for a declaratory decision as to the constitutionality and the meaning, application, and effect of Petition 90066, which was approved by the Special Session of the General Conference on February 26.

In the request filed today (March 6, 2019) and signed by COB Secretary Bishop Mande Muyombo, the COB noted that bishops voted to make the request during their meeting in St. Louis, Missouri, on February 27, 2019, a day after the close of the Special Session.

Petition 90066 was adopted in the Legislative Committee of the General Conference on February 25, adding a new Section and new paragraph 2553 and to the Book of Discipline on “Disaffiliation of Local Churches Over Issues Related to Human Sexuality.” The petition was amended during the plenary session of the General Conference on February 26 by substitution of a minority report.

The COB contends that in Decision 1377, Petition 90066 was held to violate Paragraph 33 because it omitted the annual conference as the body ratifying a local church vote to change affiliation. Therefore, the Judicial Council ruled that the petition was unconstitutional.

“The amendment made by adoption of the minority report does not cure the constitutional problem with the petition,” COB argues in its request. “There still is no requirement that the decision of the local church be ratified by the annual conference. Therefore, the COB believes the amended petition is also unconstitutional.”

The Judicial Council is scheduled to meet April 23-26 in Evanston, Illinois.

News & Announcements

Pentecost Serrvice 25 Preach Cmyk

Fourteen Churches Unite for Pentecost worship

On Pentecost Sunday, 14 United Methodist churches from the Prairie North District gathered at Freeport’s historic Oakdale Tabernacle for a powerful worship celebration filled wit…

Grace Over Fear Cmyk

From Your Bishop: Subvert Fear With Grace

In his latest column, Bishop Schwerin reflects on the legacy of fear-driven policies like the Japanese American internment during World War II, lifting up stories of resilience throug…

Cabinet Selfie Cmyk

This Life-Changing Journey: God Extends Grace; Let Us Do the Same

In her reflection, Rev. Danita R. Anderson celebrates Annual Conference 2025 and recalls her own ordination journey, now over four decades in ministry. She lif…

Selling Merchcmyk

Stronger Together: It Takes a Village!

In her column, Rev. Fabiola Grandon-Mayer reflects on the spirit of unity and collaboration that made the 2025 Annual Conference a meaningful and inspiring gathering. From worship to legi…

Print